Season 3 coming 2027
The Democratic Dilemma

Episodes/Episode 109

Former PA Secretary of Education Reveals What's Really Happening to Our Schools (feat. Dr. Khalid Mumin)

April 13, 2026 · 1 hr 22 min · with Dr. Khalid Mumin

Mary talks with Dr. Khalid Mumin, former Pennsylvania Secretary of Education and superintendent of the Reading School District. He explains the three buckets that fund a public school, why one district gets $23,000 per student and another $13,000, where a parent goes to get something changed, and how to sit on a polarized school board.

Transcript

Lightly edited for clarity. Fillers and false starts removed, nothing paraphrased.

How a kid from Logan became Pennsylvania's Secretary of Education

Mary Noone0:00

Thank you. So thank you so much for joining us during this very interesting time in terms of funding for public education and what's happening to our children. A little background, which we will dive into, public education, your experience, your entry into this space, but more so about how we can help candidates best understand the challenges our education systems are facing and how they can position themselves to work best for the children. And to be able to, we'll talk about school boards, and to be able to talk to parents in a way that helps them position themselves to better address all the community needs as a collective. And as you know, we're in a very polarized time right now.

And at the end of the day, I've always said education is the great equalizer, and we've lost that. So how do we get back to that? How do we put the kids first? With that being said, I really love to dive in and get a little bit more on your background. How did you find your way into being the Secretary of Education under Governor Josh Shapiro? And currently you are the superintendent of Reading Public Schools in Pennsylvania, and then you also have some other experience in Merion County as their superintendent. But I'm sure there were some stories to the journey along the way, and I'd love to dive into it.

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:48

Yes. I too believe that education is the great equalizer, which provides the opportunity for students or young people to really have their fingerprints on the design of their future. My life story is that I'm a young man who was raised in a single-parent home in the most underserved community in the city of Philadelphia, which is Logan, which since 1974 has been the most underserved community. Education was that one tool, that one thing that helped me to elevate. I knew the importance of education because of my mother and her history, and watching her on a typewriter work through Jefferson University, and we were able to move out of poverty all because of education. So I had that in the forefront of my mind.

I didn't quite get it at first. And then things finally sunk in, with a lot of mentors and community members who just surrounded me with love and support to work with my mom and my dad, where I did believe in the power of education.

So I went into this career, or this journey, as a teacher. And when I got into teaching, I said, this is fantastic, where I'm able to have fun with young people, have them excited about learning as an English teacher. But then I had that taste of wanting to have some influence in regards to decision making. And so I started to get on the administrative track. So I was a teacher, a dean of students, an assistant principal, a principal, a director of secondary education, and then a superintendent, all before the age of 40. So I was usually the youngest, and perhaps at many times the first African-American in these roles. So I didn't know that I was really putting together my moral compass for education as a child. I was able as a leader to just expand upon that.

And quite frankly, and God willing, I have been very successful here in the Reading School District. We're the most underserved school district in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. And the job here is to provide hope, focusing on the health, open advocacy, and passionate action of our young learners. I was here previously for seven and a half years. I moved on to Lower Merion School District, and Lower Merion, excellent, excellent education system. What I saw there was like, man, this is what a fairly funded school system looks like. And as soon as I got my feet on the ground and was rocking and rolling, I received a call from Governor-elect Shapiro, and we had a conversation. His conversation basically was, Dr. Mumin, what is your vision for education? And I'm going, my hands are moving, and I'm talking about education, adequacy funding, universal breakfast and lunch. We were talking about the higher ed system in regards to funding and costs. We were talking about mental health, and also some of the personal barriers that some of our young scholars face within school systems, and they need resources. And he said, we're going to get it. We're going to get that stuff done. And that's how I became secretary.

The three buckets that fund a public school

Mary Noone5:29

Awesome. Wow. I mean, that is an amazing story. So obviously you were creating such a footprint with the work you were doing if you're getting a call from the governor-elect, because he had heard about your work and it was like, I need to call this gentleman and offer him a seat at the table. So that is amazing. I want to drill down, not to get too much in the funding weeds, but you hit on a very important note. You talked about, you were in two different school systems, and you saw the disparities of what funding can do and what happens when you don't have the funding. And we're seeing that right now because of the current state of affairs with education across the country.

It helps for the listeners to understand there's really three brackets, correct me if I'm wrong. I'm from Massachusetts, so I was there, I was getting my master's studying public school finance when Massachusetts was passing the 1993 Ed Reform, where Massachusetts put the stake in the ground saying, we are gonna fund public education. And they have risen to be one of the highest funded public school systems. And they didn't grab on to the charter school dream that other states were grabbing onto. But there's three buckets. You get the funding from the federal government, you get the grants, and you get that bucket. And then you've got the state bucket, which you were involved in. And then you've got that local bucket that funds public education, which really is the public taxes, the property taxes, the business taxes, any of the fees that they talk about. So talk to me about, if those are the three buckets that fund education across the state, for our listeners who might not understand, why are we having some school systems rise up and others do not? Let's start there, and then we can dive into the impact that has on our scholars.

Dr. Khalid Mumin7:17

Fantastic. So I will take you back on a very short historical journey, which, again, I was moving with a moral compass, with head and heart alignment in regards to funding and adequacy. And this was back in 2014. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania did not have a fair funding formula. So each year the legislature would have to come together in regards to how much they were funding the public school systems here in Pennsylvania. With lots of advocacy, lots of support from colleagues, I was able with my team here in the Reading School District to get in front of the head of the Appropriations Committee and the head of the Education Committee while Pennsylvania was experiencing, back then, a historic impasse. We went in there with a one-sheeter. And that one-sheeter described the need for our students here in Reading to even the playing field. That meeting happened on a Thursday. That following Tuesday, Governor Wolf at the time came to Reading School District and launched the fair funding formula. So that fair funding formula addressed tax effort, poverty, and also special education learners in three tiers, from acute to multidisciplinary special ed. And there were $350 million committed to that formula.

I'm just so fortunate and blessed that I was able to work with Governor Shapiro, because the push then was, we have the funding, but we're not investing in it. There are no new dollars. And in the first budget address that Governor Shapiro presented, there was $568 million in it of new money. Last year there was 1.2 billion dollars in new money. This year it's projected to be around 1.8 billion dollars, 1.8 to 2.1 billion dollars in new dollars.

So how does that look? I had the opportunity to see it from the landscape of the most underserved school system to the most affluent school system in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The numbers are almost exact. I'm going off of numbers from two years ago, where 82 percent of the budget in the Reading School District came from the state's effort. Meanwhile, the rest was local effort, and that's taxes, and 2 percent from the feds. In Lower Merion, it was flipped upside down. 82 percent was local effort, 11 percent from the state, and again, 2 percent from the feds.

So when you talk about these three buckets, even though, when we talk about the feds, we're talking about federal policy, federal legislation, No Child Left Behind, IDEIA, and things of that nature. They are big themes with lots of dollars, but those dollars are spread out throughout all 50 states. So the numbers are massive. However, when you break down the percentages, it's 2 percent to 10 percent, basically, in any given district. Most funding here in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is going to come from those other two buckets. It's going to be heavy on state or heavy on local.

So here's the nexus. Communities that are affluent, they have a higher burden, a tax burden, which funds the district. Districts that are underserved, with learners from underserved communities, the state effort is going to be greater. The beauty of working with Governor Shapiro in the role of Secretary of Education is that Lower Merion, they have a very balanced tax base, with businesses and homes, to be able to fund the school system with that 82 percent effort. However, you have large communities of senior citizens in this affluent community, and they were able to receive rebates. So there's tax relief for seniors, just an excellent plan. On the flip side, here in the Reading School District, the state's effort increased, which closed the adequacy gaps so students can have the opportunity to have similar resources to their counterparts throughout the Commonwealth who may have very high tax bases.

So the three buckets are powerful. But when we look at the percentages, the percentages in the feds is going to be two to 10 percent. The state is going to be somewhere, depending on the affluence of the community, either high for low income or very low effort for high income. And then local, the local piece is all about the housing market and the businesses. So the thing that needed to happen here, in the role of Secretary of Education, which was just beautiful, is that sometimes when you talk about tax effort, state money, local dollars, automatically people say, it's the urban settings. And that's not the case for the most part. For the most part, it's urban settings and rural settings that don't have the capacity to build to get local effort, because the population is declining. The businesses have moved on and things of that nature. The industries have moved on in some of our areas. So when you talk about closing the gap, the adequacy gap, it is a Commonwealth of Pennsylvania phenomenon, especially delving into the spaces of AI and STEM or STEAM and things of that nature. So when you're able to have learners, scholars, students at the forefront of your discussion around these investments, it softens all of the noise. When you start to look at politics versus student or children needs, community needs, one of the things that I say very openly is that politics, this is the United States of America. We are a democracy. We have the opportunity and the freedom to make choices. Whether you choose to be a Democrat, a Republican, an independent or conservative, that's okay. It's part of our Constitution. However, when we're talking about students, absent of the politics in those four blocks, we have to be able to prepare our students for an ever-changing future. That's what it all comes down to.

So when I approach partners and legislators and other educators, it's like, school districts are very competitive. When you have programming and athletics and the arts, and then you have the assessment scores, districts become very competitive. However, we are on the same accord when it comes to every one of these young people that graduate. They're part of the future, not only of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, but for the United States of America. So you have to be looking way out and ahead, visionary, way out and ahead. It's all about preparing and equipping our students with the tools and the opportunities to chart their own course.

Dismantling the silos between K-12, higher ed and industry

Mary Noone15:16

The keyword that I heard in there was choice. Pennsylvania made a choice, regardless of where you lived, where you reside, where you grew up, where you were born, that children were going to have an education that allowed them to chart the course and path that they wanted to. So, taking away the neighborhood they grew up in, and I always used to say when I was in education, our job is to bring everybody up to the starting line. What they do after that, the journey that they choose, is up to them, but our job is to bring them up to the starting line.

And you bring up so many good points, because I don't think people, when your kids are going to school, or maybe you don't have children, they might not see how much happens in a school district, and how much time we spend on students, and how much responsibility that educators and mentors and the support staff have, and the influence they have on formulating that person who they're going to become in the future. And giving the teachers, the school, that community the right resources, it should be working hand in hand with parents as a whole collective. And what I get so disheartened by is when we have these battles in our school board and we forget about who's at the forefront of these arguments. It's the children, the children that we should be, and as parents, as I hear these arguments, I feel like looking at these parents and going, really? Are you really putting the best into your students? Because we would tell the children in the playground not to argue like that. We would say, go figure it out and go work it out. We would put them in a timeout and say, okay, go think about what you just said to so-and-so, and come back and let's work together and find a common solution.

The other thing I want to say is, you brought up a really good point. I don't know if you've seen some of the McKinsey reports that are out there. About two or three months ago, they really drilled home, and they tried to stick to exactly what you're calling out: we have to create opportunities for students and children to create a future of their choosing. And McKinsey has come out and basically said that with this push from the federal government to reshore a lot of our manufacturing, to bring back industry to a lot of our communities, specifically to rural communities, they're citing that in rural communities within a 50-mile radius, there's going to be some huge business opportunities and new jobs. The manufacturing jobs are the future. And they're actually calling out school districts saying, you're not ready for this. So talk to me about how do we get our students ready, which requires funding, for this new future that we're trying to figure out what that looks like, and how do we marry those two.

Dr. Khalid Mumin18:08

Yes, and that's a great question, Mary. One of the things that's happening now in education, and I'll speak directly to my leadership style and the challenges and successes that we've had thus far here in the Reading School District, is that one thing that's happening now, with the way that technology is moving so quickly, we as the adults, as the leaders, are coming together on the same accord in regards to, we have to prepare our young people for what's happening right now. So I am a seventies baby. And back when I graduated, I was a nineties baby in high school, and it was college or bust. Where you going? I'm going to college. Everybody's going to college. And that was celebrated. It seems as if, if you were going to college, you were placed on a pedestal, blah, blah. And we somewhat lost sight of the manufacturing jobs, the trades. I believe the pandemic helped us to refocus. We have a lot of gaps to fill. And there's nothing more powerful than working with partners in your community to see the immediate job force impact that you can have right outside of graduation.

So how does that look? It's using the school district as a hub of ideas, a hub of sharing, to bring partners together. So here in Reading, for example, the number one industry, now an industry of the future, is manufacturing. Number one. Number two is healthcare. Education comes in at number three and four, various education that's skill-up or traditional four-year programs and things of that nature, based in the areas of STEM. STEM is where it's at right now. And so here in Reading, we have the opportunity that we are surrounded by universities of different levels. Here's your skill-up: Reading Area Community College. We have a college town initiative with Alvernia University. We have Albright College on the far end of the city, or in the city. We have Penn State Berks. So now you get big Penn State. Penn State Berks is here. And Kutztown University. So now you have every single level of education right within a 10-mile radius, 10 to 15 mile radius. If it's a two-year opportunity to scale up or to gain some skills to move into the workforce, here's RACC. If it's a state school you're interested in, here's Kutztown. If you're looking for our land-grant institution, which is Penn State, one of two land-grant institutions in the Commonwealth, we've got Penn State Berks here. In Penn State, when you earn a degree from Penn State, you're now part of the second largest alumni in the world. We were number one up until about two weeks ago. If you're looking at a small private school, Albright. If you're looking for a liberal arts school that expands across areas, and they focus on business and engineering, you have Alvernia right in our backyard.

So those partners are in our buildings. They are part of our new Innovation Academy, which we will be opening the doors to in early winter. They're partners that are part of the design of this process. As I was coming up through education as a teacher and administrator, and this is what I love about where we are now as we are preparing for the future, there were silos. You have industry silos, higher ed silos, and here's the K to 12 silo. What has happened with the need to increase our workforce, especially in the trades and in manufacturing, in STEM, STEAM, engineering, and things of that nature? It has forced us to be in the room together to dismantle the silos. So that's the important piece around this. We have to be looking at this collectively. For school districts, it is not simply a school district thing. It's a community and partnership phenomenon.

Mary Noone22:43

Yeah, let me ask you this question, because I live in school choice. I live in voucher city here in Indiana, where 90 percent of our kids go to public education, but the bulk of our money goes to school vouchers. And I don't see any evidence where those schools, the public charter schools, because our public charter schools are not held to the standard, the state standard, the state testing, the state programs there. They can do their own thing. They only have to answer to their charter, whoever is holding their charter. With that being said, you have outlined Pennsylvania has taken a choice in how they want to fund kids, equity, and bring in this partnership program that really gives opportunities for various learners and students to chart a future. But I'm also hearing here in Indiana, and I'd love to hear how you folks are handling this. We just changed our diploma here, and you hear the career and technical education is the new buzzword, the CTE, they're calling it. Which is great. But what I'm also seeing is some students in some programs, and I could be reading this wrong, that's why I love to get your expertise, that are forcing them or making them choose which path to go on very early in their educational career. And I know kids pivot. I don't know what I wanted to do in seventh grade. How can I make a choice now? So then now I'm in 10th grade or 11th grade. You know what? I do want to go to that community college, but because of the path I was pushed on earlier on in my educational journey, I don't have the courses that I needed. So now I'm like, what do I do? So I'd love to hear your take on that. So you never know what your life is gonna hold, so how do we give these kids a choice? I always come back to that word, choice.

On-ramps and off-ramps instead of locked pathways

Dr. Khalid Mumin24:37

Yes, it comes down to the leadership, and understanding the vast amount of opportunities our students should be able to partake in. I tell the story like this. I wanted to be a firefighter when I was in seventh grade, because I'm a student of the 101 Dalmatians. I figured if I was a firefighter, I have a Dalmatian, and life is good. Until I put on a hundred pounds of equipment and figured out maybe this isn't the profession for me. And by the way, you have to fight fires. Oh boy, not my career. So with that example in my mind, coming from my history, programs, it's a necessity. It is essential for programs to have on-ramps and off-ramps.

Now educators, educational leaders, are looking at this where you don't want to lock students into a pathway. They should have the opportunity to explore. So the exploration, the interest level, is generated in the elementary level. That's my firefighter story. My interest is there. But then in the middle school, I get the touch. I get to touch anything that I want in regards to the arts, academics. If I want to be in debate club and I'm saying I want to be a legislator one day, or a lawyer or attorney, I can jump in and out. In the high school, the specialization starts to, those pathways start to become more defined as students are able to see what their futures, they have a clear idea of what their future may be.

Here's an example. So a student moving through, and they get to ninth grade, and they have a knack for robotics. All right. Wow. Robotics, where can that take me? They already have it. And part of the examples, you have to put the career examples in front of them, the immediate workforce examples in front of them. And you have to do the charting in regards to salary and realistic examples for our young people. So one major example that I saw, especially as Secretary of Education, I was at the CTC in Erie, Pennsylvania. There were students in pathways where they were going right out into the workforce at the end of 12th grade. They were already employed during high school. That is a locked-in pathway. You have other students who were touching on different pathways, because, hey, when I get out of school, I'm going to college. I think my first stop, I'm going to Erie Community College, and then I'll figure it out from there. Then you had other pathways where students were like, oh, I love CTC. I'm going to Penn College after graduation. So that all comes from, again, at an early age, just scaling interests. Middle school, getting your hands dirty in regards to the constructivist view of learning, where students are able to demonstrate their learning by doing. And then in high school, because now we have programming that does career and workforce inventories on students every year in their high school career. So the students are now really honing in on a realistic example of what their future can be when they graduate. That's the important piece. There's more of a diagnostic piece to this curiosity of the students' learning. It's very diagnostic.

And so you have students and families presented with data, and they say, well, your inventory, you keep putting in that you really want to become a teacher. And I'm just so happy to be back in the Reading School District, where I had students that said they wanted to be teachers when they were in high school, and now they're back. They're here as teachers. We nailed it. We hit the mark. Their inventories were precise. The courses that they were taking were precise to lead them to their goal. So it's more of a diagnostic and prescriptive process, instead of a monotonous, just put you in a pathway process that we were part of when we were younger. The students have to have choice.

Where a parent should turn, and how to serve on a polarized school board

Mary Noone29:16

If you're a parent listening to this and you're feeling like, you know what, what you're outlining is not what I'm seeing in my school system, and I've got my child in seventh or eighth grade and I'm not seeing that path, and I'm getting a little frustrated with my school system. Where should they turn? Are they going to their school board? Are they going to their state legislator? Where should they turn to try to elevate the opportunities in their local public schools?

Dr. Khalid Mumin29:44

Yes. I'm a huge proponent of, you want to simplify the process. So the best way to simplify the process: a parent has an issue, you go right to the building administration and see if that issue can be resolved there. And then if it's not resolved there, you go to the district administration. The first level is building administration. Second level is district administration, which puts you in front of the superintendent of schools. No action, go to the school board. And then from there, there's an opportunity. You've gone through the hierarchy of decision-making. Before you go just straight to the legislator and they try to push down, school systems are so unique that it causes a lot of, I would say, delay when you go all the way to the top. Deal exclusively at the local level to get that immediate change.

Now, as an example, as a superintendent here, we had a parent back in 2014, and she would come to the school board meetings, which is the local forum when you're speaking on the microphone, public comment, and she was challenging the district in regards to gifted and talented programming. Every board meeting she's coming. And one of the processes here is that in our board policy, we state, you have an issue and it's something that we can address, or the administration has a superintendent there and central office administration. During the meeting, we'll send out an administrator who's connected to the issue to take the parent's information, to bring them in for a meeting to gain more insight on their issue. Those conversations at that level, we began to work with this parent and said, what do you see in regards to gifted education that we need here in the district? And it was all about extensions of learning. To date, in 2025, that parent's input was a part of our curriculum redesign. So there is power at the local level: the building administration, central office administration, and school board. There's a lot of power there and influence.

Mary Noone32:09

Okay, what if you're a parent and you're not getting the answers you want to see, it's not coming. That outline was perfect. That's the path. That's where you're going to see the change. You get involved. You maybe get some other parents who are seeing the same thing you're seeing. Okay, you're not getting where you want to go, and now you want to run for school board. As a superintendent, how do you handle those who want to go to the school board and run for school board because they want to see change in their community and better it for everybody, and then you see those who go to the school board and their intentions are to create cultural divides within our community? Because if I'm a parent and I want to see some positive change in my community and I say, hey, well, the administration's path that you just outlined, I tried, but I'm gonna take it to the next level. I'm gonna get more in the weeds and I'm gonna run for school board. But then I hesitate, because I look at the landscape of these polarized school boards and I'm like, I don't wanna get involved in that, but I wanna be part of my community and make it grow and thrive for everybody. What kind of advice do you give the listeners if they see their school board as a hotbed of polarization, but they still wanna jump in, or they hesitate? How do you overcome that hesitation?

Dr. Khalid Mumin33:17

Yeah, well, personally, as a superintendent, and here in Pennsylvania we have nine board members on every school board in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, and they're elected officials. So the superintendent, myself, I make the commitment of being the 10th board member. And what that means is I take the responsibility to cultivate relationships with our school board members. Most times, again, they are elected. They're supported by groups of constituents to be elected into these positions. Most times it's coming from a lens or passion behind advocacy. And one of the lines that I use: advocacy, even though it may be loud, even though it may be disruptive, advocacy is not adversarial. And you build relationships. What is the issue? What information can I offer? Where is this information coming from, and what constituents do we need to better engage around these issues?

I look at it as, the one solid thing, that one piece that when you break it down, no matter what the issue is, and this has been part of my experience, if there's a student, or students, as the focal point, we can find a way to meet in the middle. If it's student driven, student centered, we can find a way to meet in the middle. As a matter of fact, as elected officials and as a leader within the school district, it's our responsibility to find a way to meet in the middle on these issues. It's all about engagement. And there are some very polarizing issues that are out there that school district superintendents and school boards have to grapple with. But, and you mentioned, Mary, the public display of angst. I look at school board and superintendent relationships as family relationships. That passion, that passionate discourse should happen. It can happen in the public eye, but you clean your issues up at the dining room table.

Advocacy again, sometimes it's soft spoken, sometimes it's loud, sometimes it has a lot of force to it, but advocacy is not adversarial as long as you're meeting in the middle in regards to leading our children to successful outcomes. Sometimes there are times that school board and superintendent relationships are strengthened through controversy, because you have to be a family. You're a family. I have a responsibility to lead a school system, and you have a responsibility to the constituents that elected you. We need to work together to get this done. So it's all about building positive, strong, sustainable relationships.

MySpace, Palm Pilots and why educators are embracing AI

Mary Noone36:33

Yeah, I can see it. What's your biggest aha moment in your journey in education? When you look at, you really wanted to push an issue and there was some controversy, but at the end of the day, it's what needed to be done, and you're like...

Dr. Khalid Mumin36:45

Yeah. When you think of theory and design, a lot of what happens in schools in real time, you cannot learn it in a textbook. Never. You have to be able to learn it on the fly, create your toolkit, because everything's not going to be perfect. You have to have a plan for a plan for a plan, in many cases. And my aha moment has been just looking into the eyes of our young people and living through them vicariously in regards to the futures that they see. I'm like, man, I would have never thought of this. Even to the extent of how we are dealing with science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. Some of the tools that we have, like the cadaver boards. If I would have had access to a cadaver board, I probably would have gone into healthcare. My mother tried to convince me to go into healthcare, and I said, Mom, I'm a good patient. I'll stay right there. I like to get service. I'm not one to be the one rendering the service. I'm squeamish of blood and needles. But if I would have had that experience with the hands-on techniques of being able to work a cadaver board, a digital cadaver board, my goodness, my interest, my curiosity would have been touched. And I perhaps would have gone that route into the sciences, into the medical sciences.

So I am just amazed at how the young people are just adapting to the future. I'll give this one example, and I don't want to be long-winded. But do you remember MySpace?

Mary Noone38:36

Oh gosh, yes. Yep, of course.

Dr. Khalid Mumin38:39

That's not gonna last. Kids are running their little Palm Pilots and all this stuff. MySpace, that ain't gonna last, blah, blah. The young people are soaking this stuff in. MySpace goes away, here comes Facebook. Oh boy, as an educator, now we gotta work. We have to work in tandem. How do we work with this tool and these other platforms within our schools to better inform our educational approaches? We were behind the eight ball. With AI now, we're all at the same starting point, and educators now are in a better stance, and we are embracing this change to be able to lead young people with these opportunities for the future, and having the confidence that perhaps this is a future that I am learning day by day. Day by day, I'm in your world, young person, because I need to help you to be able to see the opportunities that exist, which is very important.

So I marvel not only at the passion of our young people, but most importantly, their willingness to express what they need through their voices. And I'm thinking, Mary, and I'm not calling out any ages, but I'm thinking of what you're talking about with your experiences and what I'm talking about with my experiences. We come from a generation of, it's good to be seen but not heard.

Mary Noone40:20

Yep. My generation. Be nice. Play nice.

Dr. Khalid Mumin40:23

And these young people, that's right. Compliance in this generation is, I want to be heard, heard, and heard again, because they're on their devices and they want immediate feedback. That really fascinates me. It keeps me young, because I get to live through their eyes vicariously. And when they want to learn something new, I'm learning it too, because I have a responsibility to lead. And that's exciting.

Mary Noone40:50

You make a really good point, because in my space, a colleague shared with me, because the unions, we work with the unions, and they're very nervous about AI. And it has been expressed, if your campaign or your political space is using AI, we're out, we're not supporting you. And I take the stance, okay, first of all, that ship sailed. AI is here. The question is, how do we use it in an ethical way that elevates us? And I understand, appreciate their lens and their concern about how it's changing their work environment. In terms of their fear of the robotics replacing jobs, you could also flip that around and look on the horizon, as you just said, jump into it and figure out how we can create and rise together. Because that's what I'm hearing from you. So how are you hearing from your advisors? Because I have a next-door neighbor, she came home for homework help last night, because she was struggling with her English paper, and English history teacher here. So she comes over and I help her with her homework. And the question I asked, looking at the instructions from the teacher, was, are you guys allowed to use AI? And she goes, oh no. I was like, oof. She's a sophomore. And I think this is where we get to teach them how to ethically use it as a tool as opposed to a crutch. So I'd love to hear how your school system, you just started that conversation a little bit, but I know a lot of parents are curious as to how do we use AI as a tool, and how do we work with it? Are we fearful of it? Because there's a lot of mixed emotions going on right now.

Educators as lifelong learners and the conditions for student learning

Dr. Khalid Mumin42:29

Okay, and again, since we are at the starting gate, so to speak, even though AI has been around for years, we are now at a starting gate in regards to education, and how do we use these tools, and especially to prepare our young people for this ever-changing future or society. First and foremost, the educator has to commit to being a lifelong learner. I am in AI summits and symposiums. I'll be keynoting a symposium next week at Penn State. And the lens that I bring is how to address the students' curiosity around these tools. But then I learn things on the other end. I was in a meeting about two weeks ago. And since AI is so new in this space, we are the authors of the content. So you have to continually feed it. You have to continually feed these engines the information. So now you are dealing with fact and not fiction. And I think that's the greatest fear.

Here's one of my first learning experiences with AI. I was holding a big meeting as the Secretary of Education, and I wanted to explore AI and how can the Commonwealth get in front of this trend, this wave, this futuristic idea and concept. And my communications team played a speech with my voice and my content. And I listened to it. And I was like, oh, that is really good. It was a little interesting, because I'm an English teacher, I'm an English major. I'm like, oh, wow. Had my pauses, my stresses, my repetition. But I'm listening to it, and I said, oh no, that's not me, because it's missing some of the words that I always use. All right. So what did we do? We went into the engine and we better informed it. And then one time I listened to it and I was like, that's me. Unbelievable. Because I had four events in one day across the Commonwealth. And one of them, I had to approve a voiceover, and that voiceover was exact. But that came after a process of putting information in the system and forcing the algorithms of the system to be exact. That's the challenge that we have, because AI is not going anywhere. We have to be participants in this process so that we are getting authentic information, fact, and not fiction. So you gotta embrace it. And you have to embrace it by being a lifelong learner first.

Mary Noone45:21

Yeah, and that goes back to resources. Our school systems need the resources to send our educators to these conferences to level them up on these new technologies, because that is really what's going to make our students lifelong learners. Because how many teachers do we know are paying for books out of their pocket, conferences out of their pockets, additional educational workshops over the summer? So hats off to you for bringing that back to your students and your staff.

I reminded myself, gosh, this was back when I was working for Lululemon. I was there for 10 years, and I was at a conference up in Vancouver. And a gentleman was talking to us about who our customer is gonna be in the future. And he was using his young child. He had his young child on the floor playing. She had to be like two and a half. And she had an iPad in front of her. And she was navigating an iPad with her little icons and getting to her little cartoons, and happy as a clam listening to the music and navigating to the next page, the next page, and watching the little mouse do its thing. And then he hands her a Vanity Fair magazine with pictures and icons and whatnot. And she's looking at it like, it's not moving. She's looking at the pictures. It's not doing a damn thing. She's trying to swipe.

Dr. Khalid Mumin46:38

Yeah, she's trying to swipe it.

Mary Noone46:41

And you know what she did? She looked at her finger like, gosh, something's wrong with my finger. It's not working. And that's who we have to think about in terms of the technology. That two-year-old has already been exposed to that technology. How are we as educators setting them up for success for five, 10, 15 years down the road, for a future we don't even know exists yet, but it's coming really fast?

Dr. Khalid Mumin47:06

Yes, it's that practitioner point of view again. So in the commitment to being a lifelong learner, I had the same experience with my niece. She will swipe. Actually, a kid or a child iPad first was really big, so it could take the bumps. Now she has a big old phone that looks like an iPad. She's a swiper. That's what she does. She just swipes, swipes, swipes. So I was like, man, this is interesting. Okay, let me take a leap into this. And I started doing the books with swiping. And I had a huge issue with that. I like turning pages. I love to turn the pages. So what did I do? The apps, when I choose to read them on the app, mine turns pages like a book.

Mary Noone47:53

Oh, does it? That's awesome.

Dr. Khalid Mumin47:54

I adapted to it. Because again, thinking of it from an educational leadership standpoint, yes, our young people have this experience with the technology and the tools, but when it comes to the content, we are the experts. We are trained. We are the experts in those areas. So the challenge for us is to adapt to the new technologies, to be able to inform the information that's coming out of that tool into rigorous curriculum, instruction and pedagogy. So it's the commitment of the lifelong learner piece.

And you mentioned something extremely valuable, Mary. School systems, and I see this as something that I live by, must be responsible for creating the conditions for student learning. And what does that mean? That means safe and supportive schools, academics, communication and engagement, finance and organizational effectiveness, as well as partnerships. But how does that look on the adult side of it? Yeah, resources. So you go through it again. Safe and supportive school environments: for the adult, that is creating a safe space for them to generate ideas and take risks. In regards to academics, being able to have the resources to compete, and also have the opportunity to be able to inform the process around academics. Communication and engagement, that one is self-explanatory. Finance and organizational effectiveness, we have to provide the resources. They should not be coming out of their pockets in the summertime, spending up their money on school supplies and things of that nature. And the last piece, which I mentioned for the students, partnerships. Those are those professional development opportunities. Those are the engagement opportunities we have with our teachers and our staff to say, I need more help in this area. And we're able to partner and create systems and partnerships that they can find valuable to better inform their influence as an educator.

$23,000 per student versus $13,000, and dismantling the Department of Education

Mary Noone50:14

Yeah, I mean, you must go to so many conferences, having been exposed to a lot of different mindsets and theories and philosophies on how to educate. And I think a lot of people may not, and we're going back to those three buckets that I was talking about. As we have this new frontier, as the history teacher, you had the Industrial Revolution. We are on another revolution right now. Our kids are going to be impacted greatly by AI and what's happening. And then you look at Pennsylvania, going back to resources, because I'm a big believer, if we don't set our students up for success, then that's on us as adults. And how do you set our students up for success? We set our educators up for success. We give them the tools and resources they need.

So you look at Pennsylvania. On average, it's about $22,000 per student that they get funded when you add those buckets up. That's the benchmark you guys are aiming for. I think Pennsylvania is like 23, Massachusetts like 22. And then I want to get into Indiana, because Indiana is down at 14 and Oklahoma is like at 13. And you wonder why our schools are struggling. If we don't put the stake in the ground and say education is a priority, then our students are not gonna be set up for success for a future that they wanna choose. It's almost like I feel like we're choosing for them, because we're not making education a priority.

So as we enter this new, you've got the Secretary of Education. I mean, she does have the title, but her background isn't even in education right now. So when you're an educator and a superintendent going around to these national conferences and talking to other educators in other states, is there a movement? Is there a conversation about, we are at a new precipice here? Are we going to change how we fund education? Are we going to really still focus on state-level funding as our way to educate? I know that we're dismantling the Department of Education. They're trying to. I think that's a major, major mistake. What are the conversations like? Where are we going with this? Because it so impacts our future generations. At the core of what we're talking about is the children.

Dr. Khalid Mumin52:36

So I'll look at this in two ways, Mary. We talked about the state funding mechanism in regards to funding schools here in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. And then you have the federal arm to this. I've used language earlier in our conversation that the federal arm is usually theme-based, based on legislation at the federal level. So the importance at the federal level, we call these title funds: Title I, Title II, Title III, Title IV, Title IX. That's where the feds sit in. And those are very important areas to help support the education of those learners that are identified in these spaces and in these buckets with regards to titles. So eliminating the federal Department of Education is going to create a lot of stress on state systems, a lot of stress on state legislators, because most of those titles, they are specifically designed to help various groups of learners. Therefore, you cannot turn your back as an educator on them, because it's unconstitutional. That's important for us.

So the conversations that I've been having is that, as we're going through these times now, again, I am a pundit of, you must take care of your backyard. First and foremost, it's about our district. It's about our local legislators. It's about our local partners and our community. Now, how does this work? We have to continue to support funding, fair funding and adequacy, at the state level. How does this work? And this is me being very visionary. Our roads, our 500 school systems or school districts, our roads should meet. When we start talking about the feds, the federal government, that's what I see is happening. We are more so coming together as educators in school districts to partner, to see how we can align resources. I focus on the three E's: empowerment, efficiency, and effectiveness. How do we do this together? This is not simply a Reading School District or City of Reading thing. I am communicating with my counterparts in Berks County. This is a Berks County thing. And then Berks County is one of 67 counties in the Commonwealth. These 67 counties should be able to come together eventually on a plan that aligns us nicely, to be able to work with one voice, meaning our governor, on message, to be able to impact the influence and support of the federal government.

Mary Noone55:40

That makes a lot of sense. Where I sit, because I come from Massachusetts, that's where we were going. And if I was more embedded there, that's where they are. But my experience here is when you have all these charter schools and they're all operating on their own little island, you don't have that force in numbers. You don't have that collective unified front to solve problems together, because they're very independent entities. And right now we have our leading economists here in the state talking about our education attainment rate is plummeting. When I look at that, I'm going, okay, where's the problem? Where's the gap? Where's the hole that keeps getting drained in funding resources, not working as a collective? Because what I'm hearing is, as one of my great mentors, David Pepper, Laboratories of Autocracy, our states were supposed to be laboratories of democracy, where we experiment with what works, learn from each other. And what I'm hearing from you in the great state of Pennsylvania is when you guys work together as a united front, everybody wins.

Charter school students are our students

Dr. Khalid Mumin56:47

Correct. And again, at different levels, there are leaders, and depending if it's an education system, it's education leaders and legislators, or leaders and leaders of the parties. And then you have the governor. And one of the greatest things that I heard from Governor Josh Shapiro was this. His statement was: charter school students are our students.

Mary Noone57:19

Okay, say more, because I have this, as you can tell, I'm not bought into the charter school system that I'm experiencing here. So say more.

Dr. Khalid Mumin57:27

Well, the premise of charter school students are our students, that lowers the temperature between public and charter, which then puts us in an environment that we must work together. Under the premise and mindset of this, I am a graduate of a very large high school. When I was in high school, we had 4,000 students in there. I navigated that building. I had family there, and I was an athlete and I was into the arts. I was in all types of stuff. That building worked for me. But sometimes these large settings don't work for all kids. But if you're in a competitive stance or adversarial stance, you'll never be able to make sense of this, because the way the funding works here in Pennsylvania, it behooves us to work together, because the funding is coming from the local education agency. So what I've done as a leader here with my team, we stay engaged with our charter schools.

Mary Noone58:37

How many charter schools do you have in your district?

Dr. Khalid Mumin58:42

How many? Right, there are no brick-and-mortar charters in Reading School District. However, we have students who are in virtual charters. We have a percentage that's in virtual charters. So what do you do? The one thing that we do together is, first and foremost, we created an environment for virtual learning. So we have our own. We call it the Red Knight Academy. It's online learning. It's an option and a choice for our students and our families, because we strongly believe that there's nothing greater than having a student have a choice that they want and still be able to engage in all of the activities as their counterparts in their social circles. So that's important, without any perceived barriers.

Secondly, when we're talking about, we want our expectations, and this is where charter school law collides with the public school code. And these are things here in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania that the legislators have been, they're coming closer together to aligning this, which is great. But again, it starts with the governor here, and he said charter school students are our students. And that somewhat says, wow, gloves off, we can actually sit down and shake hands and work together, and start working on the issues that the public schools may have around funding, and the issues around what the charter schools may say, that the expectations are like a dangling carrot which you're never able to grab. So it forces us in the room to have these conversations. My focus, from my history, and how can I say this? An ineffective school is good for no children, whether it's charter or traditional public. If it's a bad school, it's bad for all kids. So the goal here is to have excellent publics and excellent charters as we're walking alongside Governor Shapiro in this work. It brings us to the table, because the essence of the charter school law here in Pennsylvania is for charters to offer something beyond what the traditional public school can offer.

Mary Noone1:01:27

That right there, say that again, please, because I think that's what separates state to state and how they handle their charter schools. So can you say that again?

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:01:36

Yes. Charter school law states that charter schools shall be able to have programming that goes beyond the scope of the LEA, the local education agency, meaning the public school. So if we were to look at this and just simplify it, for example, you have a large comprehensive high school in your school district, or nothing but large comprehensive high schools. Perhaps this is a charter school that focuses on STEM. It's going beyond what the traditional public school can offer. One. Two, there's language in there that the achievement of the charter needs to exceed the achievement of the local public school.

Mary Noone1:02:28

Another great point. Say that again, because that's really what our charter people need to hear. Say that again. I'm just pulling out these pieces, because that's what makes it successful.

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:02:34

Right. It's a unique programming that is not offered by the traditional public school, and they're able to excel in regards to standardized testing, summative assessments, more so than the local education agency or public school district. That's where the hangup comes out. And so, well, you're asking for something more than what the public schools ask for, or we're providing this program and they don't have it. That's where the dialogue has been strengthened. Not only amongst the educators within the school districts in the Commonwealth, and we're broken down by intermediate units. It's happening at the legislature also, because you have to bring these leaders, the charter leaders as well as the public school leaders, in the room to be able to design systems that are consistent. So you are comparing apples to apples. So it's an ongoing process. But Mary, as we talked about earlier, it's a slow process, because the way this started, in many cases, it started adversarial. So it's a work in progress.

The student who wanted culinary school, and why relationships are the one constant

Mary Noone1:04:02

Yeah, you've got to get people in the room to have the conversation. I was an educator. We all know everybody learns differently, having been through classrooms and sat in our various classrooms. And we do need to give these opportunities. I had a student, I'll never forget him. The school system that I was teaching in was your classic 400 kids per graduating class. Most kids were tracked to go to a four-year institution at that school. It had a few trades, it had an amazing auto mechanics department, but this student loved to cook. His father owned a restaurant and he wanted to go to culinary arts, but the way that the school that provided him that opportunity made this student, which we have to get better at, made him feel like the other. We were separating him out from his community, which we don't want to do to our students. So he came back, and he was a little bit of a troublemaker because he couldn't find his place. We all know as educators that students who are misbehaving in school, there's something else going on. Kids don't want to be the problem children. There's something else at the root of it. And when he was misbehaving, it was because he really wanted to pursue this career, this opportunity in culinary arts.

So he finds his way back because he didn't like that other school. And it was my job to get him to graduate. He was in my class. He was a senior, and this was a sophomore-level class. And his buddy, you know how the schools have internal communication systems, I get the message that his buddy is getting suspended, and to make sure to keep him away from my student, because they ran together. So the student that was suspended is coming by my classroom and trying to get my student, who I'm trying to get to pass one of two final tests he needs to pass, out into the hallway and to leave the school. And I find myself between these two large students, these two large boys who were in confrontation, and I don't want to let him go. My whole classroom standing up. The student that I'm trying to protect ends up touching me. Okay. And then my whole students were like, oh my God, they're going to hit the teacher. A student in the back goes into the back of the classroom, through the private doorway, and gets another teacher. The students take off. The student that touched me froze, and the other teacher comes and gets them and brings them down to the principal's office. And at the time period, one of my family's good friends was the head of the union, and he comes immediately and he says, do you want him suspended and out of here forever? Because you're not allowed to, obviously, touch a teacher. And I said, no. I said, absolutely not.

I get down into the principal's office and this student finally opened up, broke down, and he was really crying. And I tell you this story because he wanted a place to belong. And he also wanted somebody to see him. And I saw him. And I was like, nope, he's not gonna be suspended, not on my watch. We're gonna get him to graduate and get him to go off to a culinary school that makes sense for him. But that's all kids want. And that's our job as community leaders, as educators, is to create a place of belonging that nurtures their hopes and dreams.

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:07:15

Absolutely. And I mentioned earlier in our conversation, I operate off of the premise of, we have to create the conditions for student learning. And the acronym that I have in my mind is about hope, and it's hope, open advocacy, passionate action and empathy. Students want to be heard, and they want adults that are champions for them, that love them, even love them at their worst times when they make a mistake, and even at their best. So as a leader, you demonstrate that. As a teacher, I learned this as a teacher: I deal with the discipline issue, get that out of the way, and then I'm working on the parts of restoration, or the restorative pieces, because it's all about relationships. And it's fascinating the things that students depend on their teachers for and their educators for. We still have to keep in mind that these are children, and children make mistakes, even though they may come in big bodies at times.

Mary Noone1:08:18

Yes, they were bigger. They were much bigger than me.

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:08:20

Yeah, they come in big bodies, but developmentally, up here, they're children. So it's our responsibility to continue to work with them, because sooner or later, sooner rather than later, they're gonna be out in the real world. You want to make sure that you've provided them with skills at open advocacy, passion, action, and empathy, where they understand that yes, there are consequences, but hey, wait a minute, Ms. Noone, I remember her talking to me about this. I'm not going down that pathway. It's very, very important. Boy, I'm thinking of some of my... I just told this story, and where I'm connected to the students of this day. Because I ran into her at a professional basketball game, her and her sister, they're twins. And I was like, I talk about you all the time, because your sister was like, a student, perfect, perfect, perfect. And you just gave me a run for my money every single time. To hear where she was in her career as a nurse, I was like, man, you were talking about nursing when you were in ninth grade. I am so proud of you. But that student who gave me one of my most difficult challenges as a first-year teacher, my goodness.

Mary Noone1:09:44

We all remember those, right?

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:09:46

She gave me a run for my money big time. But I learned so much from her, and I learned, why is she so disruptive and why is her sister so different? Well, they were dealing with grief. Their father was killed. So the older twin by 11 minutes, she handled grief quietly, while her twin handled grief out. And once I got down to that and I started to understand, that was a long time ago, where back then I could say, I know how you feel. I can work with you. Nowadays, when I speak to young people, I say, wow, that's so complex. I don't know how you feel. I've never experienced that, but how can I help you? I want to help you. You are my student. And I'm quick to always say, and I do this with authenticity, I say, you know I love you, right? I love you, man. And I need you to give a little bit more.

And no matter how much technology comes before us, or how much curriculum and instruction and pedagogy change and tools change, the one constant force is relationships. When a student knows that you believe in them, they will work hard to meet high expectations and not disappoint you. But it's hard work. It's hard work, because some of those challenging days are extremely challenging. But you have to be able to continually refuel. And one thing that I always live by, and I used to tell the students this, I said, I don't keep grudges. What happened today happens today. I'll deal with today today and tomorrow tomorrow. You got a lunch detention, man, but I'm past that. Let's go, what we doing today? I love you, man. I need you to work a little harder, and I don't like having you in lunch detention. Let's move on. It's relationships.

Because as young people become adults, schools should be the safest places for them. Sometimes bad days as an adult, you don't get a mulligan like in golf. You don't get a replay. You don't get a break. And we are responsible for working with young people where they understand their decision-making, and sometimes they make mistakes, but they should be able to be restored after those mistakes and hurdles, shortcomings at times.

The 10 educator commitments and why education is democracy

Mary Noone1:12:50

I am so honored to have had this conversation with you, because it just reminds us, and I hope it reminds the listeners, of how much educators contribute to our communities, to the growth of our young people, to our futures. If I could have a blank check, if I was sitting in the Oval Office, I would be making a mandatory minimum salary for teachers, educators. Their education gets paid for, because what you do creates our future. And I cannot thank you enough, because having been a teacher, having been in a classroom, those little things and how teachers show up every day impact. Those little things, you don't know what's happening or who's listening or what you're saying, but how you show up. Our teachers have to show up every day and be on 120 percent. They can't leave, they can't show up 50 percent and hide in their cubicle and hope the day is, watch the clock till it's over. They are on. From the minute they walk in that building, they are on. And educators, we need to be celebrating our educators, supporting them through resources in our communities. We need to be supporting them with after-school programs. When they call us and say, can you come to this? We need to say yes. And we need to stand by them and work with our educators, and volunteer in your school boards. You want to run for school board? Run for school boards and work with your administrations. I love that ladder that you described, of where the change really can happen. You work with your administrator, you work with your district, you work with your school board, and then you go to your state legislators. Because I think we have a tendency, when we see a problem in this environment right now, it's like the answer's over here. And it's work smarter, not harder, and work locally, is what I'm learning from this conversation. I had to be reminded that that's where the change happens, is really within our own community.

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:14:48

And there's great power, Mary, when you go through those various stages and levels. Sometimes there are problems that aren't resolved at the local level. But there's nothing more powerful than when you have the school board and you have the superintendent alongside you, with other community partners, going to your legislators looking for results. I have a lot of faith in the power of the local school districts.

And you've really sparked some, when you start talking about educators and how teachers approach teaching and learning and things of that nature. And I'm going to try to do this off the top of my head. When I published a book, it's Problem Child, and that is Leading Students Living in Poverty to Infinite Possibilities of Success. And one of the pieces that I have in there, in regards to that celebration and the push for educators, I call it the 10 educator commitments. It's the commitments; the commandments were written by someone else, someone more influential than me. But that excitement in regards to, we always are talking about the students' curiosity, but what about the curiosity and passion that educators enter these professions with?

And I say, number one is give 100 percent of yourself, 100 percent of the time. Number two, believe in your influence as an educator. Number three, meet students where they are and push them to infinite possibilities of success. This is one of my favorite ones, as it comes to mind. It reminds me of my first year teaching. Don't major in the minors in terms of making mistakes. You're gonna get another crack at it the next day. Number five, you have to be an active participant in the learning of your students. That's that lifelong learning piece. Six, and this is where educators, my goodness, this separates the good and the crème de la crème. Number six, educators shall be, it's a necessity for them to be visible in the communities that they serve. My goodness, you get so many points with students when you're visible as an educator, and you have to make that commitment. You also have to be able to meet the students' curiosity about learning, because they are fired up on things and you gotta be just as fired up, and being able to step out there with confidence and lead. And this word we've used over and over in education: you have to differentiate your approaches that you have with students. There's no one size fits all. And I know number 10 off the top of my head, that's believe, believe, believe.

Yes, educators are powerful resources and leaders in these spaces. They have children in front of them eight hours a day. There is a golden opportunity to really have our fingerprints on the design, not only the design of the future, but also the human capital that's going to be able to lead us in this future. And what we're going to get out of it, we're going to get doctors and scientists and craftsmen, things of that nature, doctors and leaders in these spaces. And we have to take that on as our responsibility, that we are not running the race anymore. We ran our race. This is a marathon. We're now on the side and we're throwing the potassium and the Gatorades while these young people are running the race. We're supporting. We're the lead car, if this is NASCAR, and things of that nature. And we have to believe in that. Our influence is powerful as educators.

Mary Noone1:19:00

That is so true. And you know what? Cliché as it may be, it does take a village. It takes the village to raise these young people, especially in this environment, the social media, the exposure, everything that they have in front of them, the challenges. Oh my gosh, I am so grateful for this conversation. I could sit here for another hour, go get a cup of coffee and have us all come back and keep talking. I really hope that through this conversation, listeners hear the value of our education, the value of those like yourself that are in there leading the charge, putting the children at the forefront, keeping them at the center of all your decisions. I am honored to have had this conversation with you, because it just reminds us, the folks that are on the outside that want to see change in education, it's a really good reminder of why we are doing this and how to do this: having the focus of the children, and having the focus that we're all in this together, and being the adults in the room, and not arguing about the little things, left or right, up or down. We have to do what's right or wrong. And I think if we're focusing on what's right or wrong for our children, and using the educators as the North Star, because you are the experts, and working with our educators, then we're going to raise some really nice young folks.

Dr. Khalid Mumin1:20:25

That's right, the commitment to meet in the middle for the greater good. Got to meet in the middle. And when you're working together, sometimes you don't get everything you want. And the person on the other side of the table feels the same way. But if you can meet in the middle in the best interest of children, hey, that's a win. That is a win for all of us. Education is the great equalizer. Education is responsible for a lot of learners, a lot of success stories, a lot of scientists and entrepreneurs and teachers and educators and legislators, et cetera. And we have to continue to believe in that. And that goes back to, and I don't want to prolong the conversation, but just think back. It's 1916, Democracy and Education by John Dewey. Everything we're talking about now and grappling over now, he was talking about in 1916. Education is the pathway to our future success. And pathway, like we said, it's workforce, it's higher ed, it's entrepreneurism. There are a lot of opportunities, but that key they have in the power of having information is key, and education. Education is democracy. John Dewey said education and democracy. I say education is democracy. So yes.

Mary Noone1:22:02

That is a perfect way to end on a note. Education is.